| Platinum | Mamma Onesta's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Capri Sogno |
| Silver | Olive Garden |
| Bronze | Little Joe's Famous Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ats-A-Nice Pizza |
| Top Pick | Big Sammy's Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | Cucina Fresca Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Papa Joe's of Lockport |
| Top Pick | Syl's Restaurant & Lounge |