| Platinum | Linda's Pizza |
| Gold | Cemeno's Pizza |
| Silver | Maurie's Table |
| Bronze | Beggar's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Al's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Aurelio's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Harold's Shrimp Chicken |
| Top Pick | Joliet - Lou Malnati's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Luigi's Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Paisano's Pizza & Italian Restaurant |